| Nakamura, Hi2792 | ½-½ | Caruana, F2792 | Titled Tue 30th Jun 2026 | 2026 |
| Nakamura, Hi2810 | 1-0 | Caruana, F2795 | FIDE Candidates 2026 | 2026 |
| Caruana, F2795 | 1-0 | Nakamura, Hi2810 | FIDE Candidates 2026 | 2026 |
| Caruana, F2795 | 1-0 | Nakamura, Hi2810 | 1st 3-0 Thu 19th Feb 2026 | 2026 |
| Nakamura, Hi2810 | ½-½ | Caruana, F2795 | Titled Tue 17th Feb 2026 | 2026 |
| Nakamura, Hi2810 | 1-0 | Caruana, F2795 | 2nd 3-0 Thu 1st Jan 2026 | 2026 |
| Nakamura, Hi2810 | ½-½ | Caruana, F2795 | TechM GCL 2025 | 2025 |
| Caruana, F2795 | ½-½ | Nakamura, Hi2810 | TechM GCL 2025 | 2025 |
| Nakamura, Hi2816 | 0-1 | Caruana, F2789 | Clutch Chess: Champions | 2025 |
| Caruana, F2789 | ½-½ | Nakamura, Hi2816 | Clutch Chess: Champions | 2025 |
| Caruana, F2789 | 0-1 | Nakamura, Hi2816 | Clutch Chess: Champions | 2025 |
| Nakamura, Hi2816 | 0-1 | Caruana, F2789 | Clutch Chess: Champions | 2025 |
| Nakamura, Hi2816 | 1-0 | Caruana, F2789 | Clutch Chess: Champions | 2025 |
| Caruana, F2789 | 1-0 | Nakamura, Hi2816 | Clutch Chess: Champions | 2025 |
| Nakamura, Hi2816 | ½-½ | Caruana, F2789 | Titled Tue 7th Oct 2025 | 2025 |
| Nakamura, Hi2807 | 1-0 | Caruana, F2789 | Titled Tue 23rd Sep 2025 | 2025 |
| Caruana, F2784 | ½-½ | Nakamura, Hi2807 | Titled Tue 26th Aug Late | 2025 |
| Caruana, F2777 | ½-½ | Nakamura, Hi2804 | Titled Tue 24th Jun Late | 2025 |
| Nakamura, Hi2804 | ½-½ | Caruana, F2776 | 13th Norway Armageddon | 2025 |
| Nakamura, Hi2804 | ½-½ | Caruana, F2776 | 13th Norway Chess 2025 | 2025 |
| Caruana, F2776 | 0-1 | Nakamura, Hi2804 | 13th Norway Chess 2025 | 2025 |
| Nakamura, Hi2804 | 1-0 | Caruana, F2776 | Titled Tue 29th Apr Early | 2025 |
| Caruana, F2783 | ½-½ | Nakamura, Hi2802 | American Cup Champ | 2025 |
| Nakamura, Hi2802 | 1-0 | Caruana, F2783 | American Cup Champ | 2025 |
| Nakamura, Hi2802 | ½-½ | Caruana, F2783 | American Cup Champ | 2025 |
| Caruana, F2783 | 0-1 | Nakamura, Hi2802 | American Cup Champ | 2025 |
| Caruana, F2783 | ½-½ | Nakamura, Hi2802 | American Cup Champ | 2025 |
| Nakamura, Hi2802 | ½-½ | Caruana, F2783 | American Cup Champ | 2025 |
| Nakamura, Hi2802 | 0-1 | Caruana, F2783 | Champions Showdown Kings | 2025 |
| Caruana, F2783 | ½-½ | Nakamura, Hi2802 | Champions Showdown Kings | 2025 |
| Caruana, F2783 | ½-½ | Nakamura, Hi2802 | Champions Showdown Kings | 2025 |
| Caruana, F2803 | 0-1 | Nakamura, Hi2802 | Titled Tue 25th Feb Late | 2025 |
| Caruana, F2803 | ½-½ | Nakamura, Hi2802 | Titled Tue 14th Jan Early | 2025 |
| Nakamura, Hi2802 | 1-0 | Caruana, F2805 | Titled Tue 5th Nov Late | 2024 |
| Caruana, F2793 | ½-½ | Nakamura, Hi2802 | Saint Louis Blitz 2024 | 2024 |
| Nakamura, Hi2802 | 0-1 | Caruana, F2793 | Saint Louis Blitz 2024 | 2024 |
| Nakamura, Hi2802 | 1-0 | Caruana, F2793 | Saint Louis Rapid 2024 | 2024 |
| Nakamura, Hi2802 | ½-½ | Caruana, F2796 | CrunchLabs Masters PlayIn | 2024 |
| Caruana, F2796 | 0-1 | Nakamura, Hi2802 | Titled Tue 9th Jul Late | 2024 |
| Nakamura, Hi2794 | 0-1 | Caruana, F2805 | 12th Norway Armageddon | 2024 |
| Nakamura, Hi2794 | ½-½ | Caruana, F2805 | 12th Norway Chess 2024 | 2024 |
| Caruana, F2805 | 0-1 | Nakamura, Hi2794 | 12th Norway Armageddon | 2024 |
| Caruana, F2805 | ½-½ | Nakamura, Hi2794 | 12th Norway Chess 2024 | 2024 |
| Nakamura, Hi2795 | 1-0 | Caruana, F2805 | Titled Tue 14th May Late | 2024 |
| Nakamura, Hi2789 | 1-0 | Caruana, F2803 | FIDE Candidates 2024 | 2024 |
| Caruana, F2803 | ½-½ | Nakamura, Hi2789 | FIDE Candidates 2024 | 2024 |
| Nakamura, Hi2789 | ½-½ | Caruana, F2804 | Titled Tue 19th Mar Late | 2024 |
| Nakamura, Hi2788 | ½-½ | Caruana, F2804 | Titled Tue 2nd Jan Late | 2024 |
| Caruana, F2794 | 1-0 | Nakamura, Hi2788 | CCT Final Playoff 2023 | 2023 |
| Nakamura, Hi2788 | ½-½ | Caruana, F2794 | CCT Final Playoff 2023 | 2023 |
| Caruana, F2794 | ½-½ | Nakamura, Hi2788 | CCT Final Playoff 2023 | 2023 |
| Nakamura, Hi2780 | 1-0 | Caruana, F2786 | FIDE Grand Swiss 2023 | 2023 |
| Caruana, F2786 | ½-½ | Nakamura, Hi2780 | Titled Tue 3rd Oct Late | 2023 |
| Nakamura, Hi2780 | 0-1 | Caruana, F2786 | chess.com SpeedChess 2023 | 2023 |
| Caruana, F2786 | 0-1 | Nakamura, Hi2780 | chess.com SpeedChess 2023 | 2023 |
| Nakamura, Hi2780 | 1-0 | Caruana, F2786 | chess.com SpeedChess 2023 | 2023 |
| Caruana, F2786 | 0-1 | Nakamura, Hi2780 | chess.com SpeedChess 2023 | 2023 |
| Nakamura, Hi2780 | 1-0 | Caruana, F2786 | chess.com SpeedChess 2023 | 2023 |
| Caruana, F2786 | 0-1 | Nakamura, Hi2780 | chess.com SpeedChess 2023 | 2023 |
| Nakamura, Hi2780 | 1-0 | Caruana, F2786 | chess.com SpeedChess 2023 | 2023 |
| Caruana, F2786 | 1-0 | Nakamura, Hi2780 | chess.com SpeedChess 2023 | 2023 |
| Nakamura, Hi2780 | ½-½ | Caruana, F2786 | chess.com SpeedChess 2023 | 2023 |
| Caruana, F2786 | 0-1 | Nakamura, Hi2780 | chess.com SpeedChess 2023 | 2023 |
| Nakamura, Hi2780 | 1-0 | Caruana, F2786 | chess.com SpeedChess 2023 | 2023 |
| Caruana, F2786 | 1-0 | Nakamura, Hi2780 | chess.com SpeedChess 2023 | 2023 |
| Nakamura, Hi2780 | 1-0 | Caruana, F2786 | chess.com SpeedChess 2023 | 2023 |
| Caruana, F2786 | ½-½ | Nakamura, Hi2780 | chess.com SpeedChess 2023 | 2023 |
| Nakamura, Hi2780 | ½-½ | Caruana, F2786 | chess.com SpeedChess 2023 | 2023 |
| Caruana, F2786 | 0-1 | Nakamura, Hi2780 | chess.com SpeedChess 2023 | 2023 |
| Nakamura, Hi2780 | 1-0 | Caruana, F2786 | chess.com SpeedChess 2023 | 2023 |
| Caruana, F2786 | ½-½ | Nakamura, Hi2780 | chess.com SpeedChess 2023 | 2023 |
| Nakamura, Hi2780 | 1-0 | Caruana, F2786 | chess.com SpeedChess 2023 | 2023 |
| Caruana, F2786 | ½-½ | Nakamura, Hi2780 | chess.com SpeedChess 2023 | 2023 |
| Nakamura, Hi2780 | 0-1 | Caruana, F2786 | chess.com SpeedChess 2023 | 2023 |
| Caruana, F2786 | ½-½ | Nakamura, Hi2780 | chess.com SpeedChess 2023 | 2023 |
| Nakamura, Hi2780 | 1-0 | Caruana, F2786 | chess.com SpeedChess 2023 | 2023 |
| Caruana, F2786 | ½-½ | Nakamura, Hi2780 | chess.com SpeedChess 2023 | 2023 |
| Nakamura, Hi2780 | 1-0 | Caruana, F2786 | chess.com SpeedChess 2023 | 2023 |
| Caruana, F2786 | 0-1 | Nakamura, Hi2780 | chess.com SpeedChess 2023 | 2023 |
| Nakamura, Hi2780 | 0-1 | Caruana, F2786 | chess.com SpeedChess 2023 | 2023 |
| Nakamura, Hi2780 | 0-1 | Caruana, F2786 | Titled Tue 5th Sep Late | 2023 |
| Nakamura, Hi2787 | ½-½ | Caruana, F2782 | Titled Tue 11th Jul Late | 2023 |
| Caruana, F2773 | ½-½ | Nakamura, Hi2775 | Titled Tue 13th Jun Early | 2023 |
| Nakamura, Hi2775 | 1-0 | Caruana, F2764 | 11th Norway Chess 2023 | 2023 |
| Nakamura, Hi2775 | 0-1 | Caruana, F2764 | 11th Norway Blitz 2023 | 2023 |
| Nakamura, Hi2775 | ½-½ | Caruana, F2764 | Titled Tue 23rd May Late | 2023 |
| Nakamura, Hi2775 | ½-½ | Caruana, F2764 | PRO League KO 2023 | 2023 |
| Caruana, F2764 | 1-0 | Nakamura, Hi2775 | Titled Tue 18th Apr Late | 2023 |
| Caruana, F2764 | 1-0 | Nakamura, Hi2775 | Titled Tue 11th Apr Late | 2023 |
| Caruana, F2764 | 0-1 | Nakamura, Hi2775 | Chessable Masters Div 1 W | 2023 |
| Nakamura, Hi2775 | 0-1 | Caruana, F2764 | Chessable Masters Div 1 W | 2023 |
| Caruana, F2764 | 0-1 | Nakamura, Hi2775 | Chessable Masters Div 1 W | 2023 |
| Nakamura, Hi2775 | 1-0 | Caruana, F2764 | Chessable Masters Div 1 W | 2023 |
| Caruana, F2764 | 0-1 | Nakamura, Hi2775 | Chessable Masters Div 1 W | 2023 |
| Nakamura, Hi2775 | 0-1 | Caruana, F2764 | Chessable Masters Div 1 W | 2023 |
| Caruana, F2764 | 0-1 | Nakamura, Hi2775 | Chessable Masters Div 1 W | 2023 |
| Caruana, F2764 | 1-0 | Nakamura, Hi2775 | Chessable Masters Div 1 W | 2023 |
| Nakamura, Hi2775 | ½-½ | Caruana, F2764 | Chessable Masters Div 1 W | 2023 |
| Caruana, F2764 | 1-0 | Nakamura, Hi2775 | Chessable Masters Div 1 W | 2023 |
| Caruana, F2766 | 1-0 | Nakamura, Hi2768 | Titled Tue 21st Feb Early | 2023 |